"Which would be worse? To live as a monster or die as a good man?" (Missing the colon and the deliberate pause).
Have you found a subtitle that caught a detail you missed before? The clues are all in the text.
"Which would be worse: to live as a monster, or to die as a good man?"
Furthermore, during the cave scene with "Dr. Rachel Solando" (Patricia Clarkson), she speaks in rapid, manic bursts. A quality will break her dialogue into short, punchy lines to reflect her breathlessness. Cheap subtitles combine her monologue into one giant text block, ruining the pacing. Legal & Ethical Considerations Is downloading a Shutter Island English subtitle file legal? Generally, yes . Subtitles are considered derivative works, but in most jurisdictions, downloading a plain text .srt file for a movie you already own (physically or digitally) falls under fair use/fair dealing.